GROWTH
How to Track Which Leads Turn Into Jobs (Simple Lead Tracking for Contractors)
Why tracking leads matters
Most small contractors know how many enquiries they get. Far fewer know how many became paid jobs, or which source those jobs came from. Without that, you cannot tell whether a marketplace, a Google ad, your website or referrals is worth the money, and you cannot see whether slow replies are costing you work.
Tracking answers three plain questions: where do my jobs come from, how many leads turn into work, and does replying faster help. You do not need software to begin.
What to record for every lead
| Field | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Date and time received | Lets you measure how long you took to reply |
| Source | Website, marketplace, ad, referral or phone. Shows which channels work |
| Job type | Shows which services bring the most work |
| Time of first reply | Your response time, the number you can change fastest |
| Status | New, contacted, quoted, closed |
| Outcome | Won or lost. The most important field |
| Job value | Lets you compare sources by revenue, not just count |
| Reason if lost | Price, timing, no reply or not a fit. Shows what to fix |
If you do nothing else, record the source and the outcome. Those two fields answer most questions.
The numbers to watch
| Metric | How to calculate it | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Lead-to-job rate | Jobs won divided by real leads (leave out spam) | How well your leads convert overall |
| Win rate | Won divided by won plus lost, ignoring leads still open | How often you win the jobs you quote |
| Average first response | Total reply time divided by number of leads | Whether you are fast enough |
| Cost per booked job | Total spend on a source divided by jobs won from it | Which sources are worth the money |
| Revenue by source | Job value added up per source | Which channel brings the most money |
Our guide on what a home service lead costs explains cost per booked job in more detail.
Three ways to track
A spreadsheet. One row per lead, with the columns above. It costs nothing and works for a few leads a week. The risk is forgetting to update it.
A CRM. A free or paid CRM keeps contacts and stages in one place and can remind you to follow up. It takes setup, and you still have to record outcomes.
Your lead tool. If leads arrive through a form, the tool can do part of this for you. In Formantly, every enquiry lands in your dashboard with a status. On each lead you can mark it Won or Lost. The Analytics page then shows how many real leads you received, how much spam was blocked and your win rate, on every plan. On Pro it also shows your average first response time and the share of resolved AI conversations that ended qualified. You can also export leads to a CSV file with the outcome included.
A weekly review in ten minutes
- Mark the outcome of every lead that has closed.
- Note the source of each job you won.
- Check your average first response. Is it getting slower?
- Look at the leads you lost and the reasons. Is one reason repeating?
- Write down one change to try next week.
What to do with what you learn
- One source brings most of your jobs. Spend more effort there, and check that its cost per job still makes sense.
- A source brings many leads but few jobs. Ask whether the leads are low quality or whether you are replying too slowly. Compare its response time with your best source.
- Many leads are lost with no reply. Speed up your first response. See how fast to respond to a home service lead.
- Many leads are lost on price. Check that your first reply asks about the job before quoting, so you are quoting the right scope.
Keep the definitions consistent
Decide once what counts as won. It might be a signed quote, a deposit or a booked date. Use the same rule every time, or your rates will drift for reasons that have nothing to do with your business. Also decide how you treat spam and duplicates, and leave them out of your lead count.
Frequently asked questions
How do I track which leads become jobs?
Record the source and the outcome for every lead, either in a spreadsheet, a CRM or your lead tool. Then divide jobs won by real leads to get your lead-to-job rate, and compare it by source.
What is a good lead-to-job rate?
It depends on your trade, your prices and where the leads come from, so there is no single number. Track your own over time and compare sources against each other.
Do I need a CRM to track leads?
No. A spreadsheet works for a small number of leads. A CRM helps as volume grows, especially for reminders and stages.
How often should I update lead outcomes?
Weekly is enough for most small businesses. The key is a fixed routine, because outcomes recorded late are less accurate.
Reply to every enquiry in minutes
Formantly captures your website enquiries and follows up automatically. Free to start.
Start Free