COSTS AND TOOLS
How Much Does a Home Service Lead Really Cost? (Angi, Thumbtack, and Your Own Site)
What cost per lead means
A lead is a homeowner who has asked for help with a job. Cost per lead is what you pay to get that request in front of you. It might be a fee per lead on a marketplace, a charge when someone contacts you through an ad, or simply your time and a small tool subscription if the lead comes from your own website.
The number is easy to compare and easy to misread, because a lead is not a customer. Some leads never answer. Some want a price you cannot match. Some were sent to several businesses at once.
Where home-service leads come from
| Source | How you pay | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Marketplaces such as Angi and Thumbtack | Usually a fee per lead, sometimes plus a membership or subscription. Terms vary by platform | Whether the lead is shared with other businesses, contract length, and what happens with bad leads |
| Google Local Services Ads | Google says you pay only when potential customers get in touch through your ads, with a weekly lead budget you choose and a monthly budget you can adjust | Verification steps, and leads that are not right for you |
| Your own website or form | No per-lead fee. Costs are a form tool, any domain or hosting, any ads you run and your time | Slower to build up, and depends on people finding you |
| Referrals and repeat customers | Usually your time, sometimes a thank-you | Volume is limited |
Google describes Local Services Ads as a pay-per-lead model. It also says verified businesses receive a Google Verified badge after checks on business registration and identity.
Why the cheapest lead can cost the most
Divide what you spend by the jobs you actually win, not by the leads you receive. This is your cost per booked job.
Cost per booked job = total spend divided by jobs won
Here is an example with invented numbers to show the idea. It is not a benchmark for any platform.
| Source A | Source B | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost per lead | $40 | $80 |
| Leads bought | 10 | 10 |
| Total spend | $400 | $800 |
| Jobs won | 2 | 5 |
| Cost per booked job | $200 | $160 |
Source A looked half the price per lead and turned out more expensive per job.
- Source A ($40 per lead)200
- Source B ($80 per lead)160
Source: Worked example in this article, not survey data
Questions to ask before you pay for leads
- Is each lead exclusive to me, or sent to other businesses too? If shared, how many?
- Do I pay for leads that never answer, and is there any credit for bad ones?
- Is there a membership, subscription or minimum contract, and how do I cancel?
- Can I cap my spending each week or month?
- How is the price set for my trade and area, and can it change?
- Can I see which leads turned into jobs?
The last question matters most. If you cannot connect leads to jobs, you cannot tell which source is worth the money. Our guide on how to track which leads turn into jobs shows a simple way to do it.
What leads from your own website cost
A lead from your own site has no per-lead fee, but it is not free. You pay for the pieces that capture and follow up on it, and your time. A shareable form link costs almost nothing to set up, as covered in how to get leads without a website.
Formantly has a Free plan, and Pro is $29 a month. See Formantly pricing for the current limits. Your own leads also convert best when you reply fast, which we cover in how fast to respond to a home service lead.
A simple way to compare sources
- Give every lead a source: marketplace, ads, website, referral.
- Record whether it became a job.
- Add up spend per source for the same period.
- Divide spend by jobs won.
- Keep the sources with the lowest cost per job that you can still handle, and question the rest.
Do this over a few months, not a week, because jobs take time to close and small numbers are noisy.
Frequently asked questions
How much does a home service lead cost?
It depends on the platform, trade and area, and prices change. We do not quote figures because we could not confirm current ones from the platforms. Check your own account, and judge each source by cost per booked job.
Is a shared lead worth paying for?
It can be, but you compete with other businesses for the same homeowner, so your win rate is usually lower. Ask how many businesses receive each lead, and factor that into your cost per job.
What is a good cost per booked job?
There is no single figure. It depends on the value of your jobs and your margins. A useful rule is that your cost per booked job should be well below the profit you make on an average job.
Are leads from my own website cheaper?
They have no per-lead fee, but they take time to build and depend on people finding your site or link. Many businesses use both: their own channels for steady work and paid platforms to fill gaps.
Reply to every enquiry in minutes
Formantly captures your website enquiries and follows up automatically. Free to start.
Start Free